With Every Breath, I Choose (Vol. 1, No. 003)

CASE FILE No. 003
VOL. I — BREATH
STATUS: OPEN
FILED BY MELROSE CASANOVA


The Case

Your heart beats without asking your permission. So does your digestion, your blood flow, your blinking. Breath is different. It runs on its own, but you can also take hold of it: slow it down, hold it, or use it to speak. It's the one rhythm of life God placed partly in your hands.

In No. 001, God breathed life into dust. In No. 002, His Spirit was already hovering before anything had shape. This file asks what comes next: if God gives breath, what do we do with it? And what if our ability to love is connected to it? Love has to be chosen. Choosing takes freedom. And all through Scripture, freedom and breath show up together.

To get there, I have to take you somewhere the air is thin.


Testimony

Years ago, before I had fully surrendered my life to God, I traveled to Machu Picchu in Peru.

You can't get there all at once. The ruins sit high in the Andes, and the change in altitude is too much for your body to take in one step. So we went up in stages. We flew into Lima, then boarded a smaller plane into the mountains. From there, we drove two hours to a train station and rode the train the rest of the way up. Each stage gave my body a little time to adjust before the next one.

Even then, the altitude caught up with me. I was short of breath and dizzy, and they kept giving me a local remedy to help me adjust. The dizzier I got, the more they gave me. I had come all that way, and I could barely focus on the view, or even on where I was headed. All I could think about was my next breath.

And yet, when I reached the top, I felt peace. I didn't have words for it then. Looking back, I believe He was already there with me, long before I had surrendered anything to Him.

I didn't know it yet, but that trip was a picture of what God was about to do in me. He didn't take me up all at once. In the years that followed, He set me free one level at a time, and each new freedom gave me room to breathe at a height I couldn't have handled before.


Exhibits

My story isn't the first time breath, freedom, and love showed up together. Scripture is full of them.

Exhibit A ·

Deuteronomy 30:19–20

"I have set before you life and death, blessing and curse. Therefore choose life, that you and your offspring may live, loving the LORD your God, obeying his voice and holding fast to him, for he is your life and length of days."

God doesn't force the choice. He sets it before them, tells them which one to pick, and then lets them choose. And notice what He calls Himself: their life.

Exhibit B ·

Exodus 6:9

"Moses spoke thus to the people of Israel, but they did not listen to Moses, because of their broken spirit and harsh slavery."

Choosing life takes breath, though. Right after God promised to set Israel free, they couldn't even hear it. The Hebrew behind "broken spirit" is qotser ruach, literally "shortness of breath." It's the same ruach that hovered over the waters in No. 002. Slavery didn't only bind their hands. It took their breath, and with it their ability to receive what God was offering.

Our bodies still work this way. Under fear and pressure, breathing often turns short and shallow, and our choices narrow to fight or flight. A people with no room to breathe had no room to choose.

Exhibit C ·

2 Corinthians 3:17–18

"Now the Lord is the Spirit, and where the Spirit of the Lord is, there is freedom. And we all, with unveiled face, beholding the glory of the Lord, are being transformed into the same image from one degree of glory to another."

Freedom isn't one moment. It's a climb. The same Spirit, the same breath, sets us free and then keeps transforming us "from one degree of glory to another." Like the trip up to Machu Picchu, He takes us up in stages, giving us time to breathe at each level before the next.

Higher in love

Here's what I'm learning: God loves us at every level. He met me with peace on that mountain before I had surrendered anything. But we can only go as high in love as we're free enough to breathe. Fear, old wounds, and the things we haven't surrendered keep us at a lower altitude. It isn't that He's holding back. We just can't breathe any higher yet.

Paul prays that we would "have strength to comprehend with all the saints what is the breadth and length and height and depth, and to know the love of Christ that surpasses knowledge" (Ephesians 3:18–19). Love has heights. And every time God sets us free from something, He brings us "out into a broad place" (Psalm 18:19): more room to breathe, and a little higher to go.

And love is a lot like breath. You breathe in, and then you have to breathe out. It is not meant to be held. Love works the same way. We receive His love, and then we give it away. Love that's only kept never becomes what it was meant to be. "We love because he first loved us" (1 John 4:19). The higher He takes us in freedom, the more we have to give.

I've learned this most in my marriage.

Juan and I had known each other since we were twelve. After fourteen years apart, we reconnected, and when I hugged him for the first time in all those years, I felt complete peace. I could finally breathe. He was a breath of fresh air.

So when I wrote my vows, I wanted him to know I would always choose him, no matter what: "With every breath, I choose you."

That choice didn't end at the altar. Juan serves as a first responder, so choosing him means not living afraid of losing him. I can't hold on to him any more than I can hold my breath. Every day, I give him back to God, and every day, I choose him again.

God's will and ours

None of this is forced. God has a perfect will, His best for us (Romans 12:2), but He doesn't make us take it. He sets it before us and gives us a real choice, because love that has no choice isn't love. And when we choose something other than His best, He stays sovereign, still able to redeem what we hand back to Him.

Supporting evidence

  • Acts 17:25. He "gives to all mankind life and breath and everything." The breath is His gift.
  • Galatians 5:1. "For freedom Christ has set us free; stand firm therefore, and do not submit again to a yoke of slavery." Freedom is the point, not a side effect.
  • 1 John 4:18. "There is no fear in love, but perfect love casts out fear." Fear tightens. Love lets us breathe.
  • Joshua 24:15. "Choose this day whom you will serve." The choice is daily.

Cross-Examination

Objection: "If God is sovereign, are my choices even real?"
Yes. Deuteronomy 30 would make no sense otherwise. God doesn't stage a choice He has already made for you. His sovereignty means He is never surprised and never defeated, not that your decisions don't count.

Objection: "What does breath have to do with love?"
Love can't be forced. It has to be chosen, and it has to be given, and both take breath. Fear keeps our breath short and our love small. But perfect love casts out fear (1 John 4:18). Each time He sets us free, we can breathe a little deeper, love a little higher, and give a little more.


Findings

  1. God gives the breath; we choose what to do with it. Life is His gift. Direction is our response.

  2. Bondage steals breath; freedom gives it back. Fear and slavery keep us short of breath. God sets us free so we can breathe again.

  3. Freedom comes in degrees, and so does love. He loves us at every level, and each new freedom takes us higher.

  4. Love, like breath, has to be given. We receive it, and we give it away.

Live it out this week: Before you make a decision, big or small, breathe in slowly and ask: "Lord, which of these is life?" Then choose it. As you breathe out, ask one more: "Who can I give Your love to today?" And if your breath feels short, notice what's holding it. Name it, and ask Him to set you free.


Status: Open · Vol. I continues

Up next: Vol. I, Case File No. 004, "The Breath of Discernment"

You can't smell anything without breathing in. In Hebrew, the word for breath and spirit, ruach, shares a root with the word for scent, reiach. Idols have noses but cannot smell, yet Isaiah says the Messiah's "delight," a word that literally means to smell, "shall be in the fear of the LORD" (Isaiah 11:3). In the next file, we'll look at what smell has to do with discernment, and how the Spirit trains us to sense what's true before we can see it.

Every life is evidence.


Open your first case file.

Join The Archive and get my free seven-day guide for examining one area of your life through Scripture, plus every new Case File delivered straight to your inbox.

Previous
Previous

The Breath of Discernment (Vol. 1, No. 004)

Next
Next

The Spirit Was There Before the Beginning (Vol. 1, No. 002)