The Breath of Discernment (Vol. 1, No. 004)

CASE FILE No. 004
VOL. I — BREATH
STATUS: OPEN
FILED BY MELROSE CASANOVA


The Case

You can't smell anything without breathing in. Scent rides on breath. Every time you inhale, you take in information about the world around you: smoke before you see the fire, spoiled food before you taste it, rain before it falls.

In No. 003, we saw what happens when bondage steals our breath. This file asks what happens when the Spirit fills it: what if discernment works like smell? In Hebrew, the word for breath and spirit, ruach, shares a root with the word for scent, reiach. The Bible ties them together more often than we notice.

I didn't learn this in a book first. For years, the sense I'm writing about was the one I had lost.


Testimony

Before I was old enough to swim, I found myself in the deep end of a diving pool. The water closed over me, and I was drowning. It had almost reached my lungs when I was pulled out and rushed to safety. It was a miracle.

And it didn't happen only once. More than once as a child, I nearly lost my breath to the water.

From then on, I grew up with sinus problems. Breathing through my nose was a constant struggle, and my sense of smell stayed dull for years.

I felt it even when I sang. I took chorus lessons growing up, but my notes always came out through my nose. No matter how hard I tried, I couldn't breathe from my diaphragm.

Looking back, I don't think it was random. The enemy went after my breath early, before I was old enough to know what it was for.

But God had the final word. Through deliverance, and through medical treatment, He healed my sinuses. For the first time in years, I could really breathe, really smell, and sing from my diaphragm.

Then, in 2023, a prophetic word found me: God would give me discernment of spirits through smell. I'm still growing into it. The sense I had nearly lost, He had quietly given back, and now He was setting it apart.

God doesn't only restore what was taken. He consecrates it.

"He sent from on high, he took me; he drew me out of many waters." (Psalm 18:16)


Discovery

My story sent me back to Scripture, and it has more to say about scent than most of us notice.

And if breath brings life, then scent is the evidence of it. Only the living can smell. God breathed life into Adam through his nostrils (Genesis 2:7), the very place we smell from, while idols, with no breath in them, have noses that smell nothing (Psalm 115:6).

Scent also tells the truth about what's alive and what's dying, often before you can see it. At Lazarus's tomb, Martha hesitated, "Lord, by this time there will be an odor" (John 11:39), and Jesus called him out anyway. Scent arrives before a person and lingers after they leave: when Mary anointed Jesus, "the house was filled with the fragrance of the perfume" (John 12:3). You can't see it, but you can't deny it, which is close to how Hebrews describes faith: "the conviction of things not seen" (Hebrews 11:1).

Even science points this way. Unlike our other senses, smell doesn't first pass through the thalamus, the brain's relay station. It travels almost straight to the areas tied to emotion and memory. That's why one scent can carry you back years in a single breath, and why discernment through smell can register before you've had time to reason it out.

And the same breath that carries scent in carries our voice out. When my sinuses were blocked, so was my voice. Smell and speech share the same doorway.

Think about what we do when something smells wrong. We cover our nose and our mouth at the same time. Before we've decided anything, the body is already guarding the doorway: what comes in, and what goes out. Discernment works the same way. When the Spirit alerts us that something isn't right, one of the first things to guard is our mouth. "Set a guard, O LORD, over my mouth; keep watch over the door of my lips!" (Psalm 141:3)

There's a Jewish teaching about this. Read Genesis 3:6 closely: the woman saw the fruit was good, she took it, and she ate it, after hearing the serpent. Sight, touch, taste, and hearing are all part of the story of the fall. Smell is never mentioned. So some Jewish teachers came to see smell as the one sense the first sin never touched. Scripture doesn't say that outright, but it's a profound thought: the sense God may use to help us discern is the one the fall didn't reach.


Exhibits

Scripture is full of people who sensed by the Spirit what others couldn't see yet.

Exhibit A ·

Luke 1:41–42

"And when Elizabeth heard the greeting of Mary, the baby leaped in her womb. And Elizabeth was filled with the Holy Spirit, and she exclaimed with a loud cry, 'Blessed are you among women, and blessed is the fruit of your womb!'"

Nobody had told Elizabeth that Mary was pregnant, let alone with the Messiah. But the moment Mary's voice reached her, Elizabeth, filled with the Holy Spirit, knew. Discernment often works this way: you sense it before you can see it, and long before you can prove it.

Exhibit B ·

Isaiah 11:2–3

"And the Spirit of the LORD shall rest upon him… the Spirit of knowledge and the fear of the LORD. And his delight shall be in the fear of the LORD. He shall not judge by what his eyes see, or decide disputes by what his ears hear."

The child Elizabeth's son would announce is the One Isaiah described. The Hebrew behind "his delight" comes from the same root as ruach, and it literally means "to smell." Many scholars read it this way: the Messiah, filled with the Spirit, would sense what is true, not only judge by what His eyes saw or His ears heard.

Exhibit C ·

Psalm 115:5–6, 8

"They have mouths, but do not speak; eyes, but do not see. They have ears, but do not hear; noses, but do not smell… Those who make them become like them; so do all who trust in them."

The opposite of the Spirit-filled sense is the idol's nose. Idols have noses but no breath (Psalm 135:17), so they can't discern anything, and the people who worship them start to lose their senses too. Most of us don't bow to statues, but we all have things we're tempted to put in God's place: approval, money, comfort, control. Whatever takes His place slowly dulls our ability to sense what's true. The Holy Spirit does the opposite. The more we breathe Him in, the sharper our discernment becomes.

Supporting evidence

  • Genesis 8:21. "And when the LORD smelled the pleasing aroma…" Scripture describes even God as one who smells.
  • Psalm 34:8. "Oh, taste and see that the LORD is good!" 
    God invites us to know Him through our senses.
  • 2 Corinthians 2:15. "We are the aroma of Christ to God."
    We don't only sense; we carry a scent too.
  • Hebrews 5:14. The mature "have their powers of discernment trained by constant practice to distinguish good from evil." Discernment is trained.
  • 1 Corinthians 12:10. The Spirit gives "to another the ability to distinguish between spirits." Some receive it as a particular gift.
  • 1 John 4:1. "Test the spirits to see whether they are from God." Every impression gets tested.

Cross-Examination

Objection: "God doesn't speak through the physical senses." Overruled. Scripture uses the senses all the time: taste and see, the aroma of Christ, a God who smells a pleasing offering. The Spirit can use anything He made. But a sense is never the final word. Every impression is tested by Scripture (1 John 4:1).

Objection: "Discernment is just suspicion with a spiritual label." Overruled. Suspicion assumes the worst. Discernment seeks the truth, and Paul ties it to love abounding (Philippians 1:9). Real discernment protects people.

Objection: "Discernment is only for the specially gifted." Overruled. Some receive a particular gift (1 Corinthians 12:10), but Hebrews says discernment is trained by practice. Everyone who has the Spirit can grow in sensing what He's doing.

Objection: "If I've prayed for healing and haven't seen it, I must not have enough faith." Overruled. Elizabeth waited years for her promise. Waiting is not a sign that God has forgotten you or that your faith failed. Keep bringing it to Him, keep wise medical care, and keep guarding what He has promised. Discernment is for the waiting season too.


Findings

  1. Scent is the evidence of life. Only the living can smell, and only what's alive gives off fragrance.

  2. Scent rides on breath. Discernment flows from the Spirit we breathe in.

  3. God doesn't only restore what was taken; He consecrates it. To consecrate is to set apart for holy use. What He gives back, He gives back with a purpose.

  4. Discernment is trained and tested. It grows with practice and always answers to the Word.

Live it out this week: Ask God: "What are You forming in me right now, and what needs to stay away from it?" Then, before you walk into a room, a conversation, or a decision, take one slow breath and pray: "Holy Spirit, help me sense what You sense." Write down anything you notice, and test it against Scripture.


Status: Open · Vol. I continues

Up next: Vol. I, Case File No. 005, "Let the Record Show"

The same breath that carries scent in carries our voice out. Every word we speak is breath given shape, and none of it disappears. "By the word of the LORD the heavens were made, and by the breath of his mouth all their host" (Psalm 33:6). In the next file, we'll follow breath from the nose to the voice to our words, and why Scripture says "death and life are in the power of the tongue" (Proverbs 18:21).

Every life is evidence.


Open your first case file.

Join The Archive and get my free seven-day guide for examining one area of your life through Scripture, plus every new Case File delivered straight to your inbox.

Next
Next

With Every Breath, I Choose (Vol. 1, No. 003)