CASE FILE No. 002
VOL. I — BREATH
STATUS: OPEN
FILED BY MELROSE CASANOVAThe Case
In Case File No. 001, we watched God breathe into dust. But that wasn't the first time His breath shows up in Scripture.
Before there was light, land, or Adam, there was darkness. The earth was formless and empty. And the Spirit of God was already there, hovering.
So the question for this file: what is God doing in the seasons before anything has taken shape?
Exhibits
Exhibit A · Genesis 1:1–2
"In the beginning, God created the heavens and the earth. The earth was without form and void, and darkness was over the face of the deep. And the Spirit of God was hovering over the face of the waters."
The Hebrew for "without form and void" is tohu wabohu: unshaped and empty. Nothing in that verse looks like progress. Yet the Spirit is present before a single word is spoken.
Exhibit B · Deuteronomy 32:11
"Like an eagle that stirs up its nest, that flutters over its young, spreading out its wings, catching them, bearing them on its pinions."
The word translated "hovering" in Genesis 1:2 is the same word used here for an eagle fluttering over its young. It isn't distance. It's close, protective, and ready to move.
Exhibit C · Psalm 104:30
"When you send forth your Spirit, they are created, and you renew the face of the ground."
The same Spirit who hovered at the beginning is still the one who creates and renews.
Supporting evidence: Psalm 33:6. "By the word of the LORD the heavens were made, and by the breath of his mouth all their host." Word and breath work together.Psalm 139:7–8. "Where shall I go from your Spirit?" There is no dark place He has left.John 1:5. "The light shines in the darkness, and the darkness has not overcome it." Darkness was never the final word.
Testimony
In late 2022, I kept sensing in prayer that I shouldn't renew my lease. I didn't know why. It was the same season I believed God was asking me to lay down my marketing agency (the one I wrote about in Case File No. 001) and serving in my local church. Then I discerned the next step: travel across the country, house to house, ministering to families.
I was still under contract where I was living, so I treated it as a trip and planned to come home. A woman I had been ministering to online invited me to her town in Arizona, and we hosted an event with a local group there. Before I left, a few of them told me, "If you ever move here, you have a room." I was grateful, but honestly confused. Moving there was the last thing I had in mind.
I drove back home to Florida, stopping to minister in Texas, Tennessee, and anywhere God sent me. Without realizing it, I was already living out something He had been revealing to me in pieces for nine years. In that season, He finally gave it a name, AVODA House, and a vision. Part of it was exactly what I was doing on that drive: going house to house, serving families.
When I got home, my roommates decided to break the lease. I had no plan for where I'd go, so I prayed. This time I believe God spoke clearly: go to Arizona and build AVODA House. When I called the group there, some of them said they had already sensed I was coming. I received it as confirmation.
I sold furniture and gave things away until my whole life fit in my car. All I took were my clothes and my books. Everything else, including my family, friends, and business, I left behind in Florida.
I didn't know exactly what He was sending me to do, or how I would do it. On paper, it didn't add up. I was a woman, going alone, with no money and no church or organization sending me. Not everyone understood.
I had no progress to point to. What I had was His presence. I saw it in mentors who stood with me, in family and friends who prayed for me, and in confirmations that kept coming: through Scripture, through prophetic words, and through a stirring I couldn't shake.
Looking back, I can see what He was doing. Before He formed the ministry, He was forming me, and He did it through His presence. In a season with no progress to show, time with Him shaped my character, my faith, my gifts, and my obedience. And when His presence was the only thing I could point to, other people's approval stopped carrying so much weight. That's how He removed the fear of man as I stepped out of what was expected of me and into what He was asking.
Nothing about that season looked like progress. It looked like loss. But He was hovering over it the whole time. He was there before the beginning.
Cross-Examination
Objection: "Isn't this just about creation, not my life?" Scripture uses the same picture again and again: the Spirit over the waters at creation, descending like a dove over the waters of Jesus' baptism, and filling the believers at Pentecost. Where He hovers, He is about to create.
Objection: "If God was there, why did it still feel empty?" Because presence and progress are not the same thing. Genesis 1:2 never says the darkness felt full. It says the Spirit was in it.
We tend to measure our seasons by progress: what got built, what changed, what we can point to. Scripture measures by presence. In Genesis 1, the Spirit's presence came first, and the progress came only after God spoke. The waters didn't have to produce anything to have Him over them.
Progress is what you can see. Presence is what makes progress possible. If you only look for progress, a hovering season will look like a wasted one. If you look for presence, you'll find He never left.
So the question isn't "Is anything happening?" It's "Is He here?" And the evidence says He is.
Findings
Presence comes before progress. The Spirit hovered before God said, "Let there be light." Don't judge a season by what you can see yet.
Formless doesn't mean forsaken. The earth was empty, but it was never alone.
The hovering season is a preparing season. What He hovers over, He is getting ready to form.
Evidence of hovering
You can't always see what God is forming, but you can learn to notice signs that He is near it. Here is what to look for before anything becomes visible:
A stirring you can't shake. A burden, question, or desire keeps coming back. Like the eagle that "stirs up its nest" (Deuteronomy 32:11), He often moves things before He builds.
Something being cleared. A season ends, a door closes, or something is emptied out. Before God formed the earth, it was "without form and void." Empty space is often room being made.
A holy pause. Plans stall and doors won't open yet, even though you're praying and obeying. The Spirit hovered before God spoke. Waiting isn't the same as being forgotten.
The same word showing up. One verse, theme, or phrase keeps finding you through Scripture, sermons, or conversations. "By the word of the LORD the heavens were made, and by the breath of his mouth" (Psalm 33:6). His word usually comes before His work.
People arriving early. Someone enters your life before you know why. God often places key people ahead of the plan they belong to.
Peace ahead of clarity. You don't have answers yet, but you have a peace you can't explain (Philippians 4:7). That peace is often presence.
Live it out this week: Name one area of your life that feels formless right now. This week, look for the evidence of hovering above and write down anything you notice. Each morning, pray, "Holy Spirit, You were here before I could see anything. Show me what You're forming."
Status: Open · Vol. I continues
Up next: Vol. I, Case File No. 003, "With Every Breath, I Choose"
Your heart beats without asking your permission. Your breath is different: God gives it, and you get to choose what to do with it. In the next file, we'll look at what breath has to do with free will, and why I put it in my wedding vows.
Every life is evidence.
Open your first case file.
Join The Archive and get my free seven-day guide for examining one area of your life through Scripture, plus every new Case File delivered straight to your inbox.